13 min · Advanced
Offers, Positioning, and Sales Messaging
State who the offer is for, the job, the alternative, and the proof you hold, and keep brainstorms separate from validated plans.
Learning objectives
- Write positioning as who, job, alternative, and proof.
- Design an offer with scope, your price logic, and explicit exclusions.
- Draft a sales message and a plan sketch that labels assumptions and refuses invented counts.
01
Why this matters
Positioning is how a buyer tells you apart from the alternative, not how clever the slogan sounds. Offers that hide exclusions create work you cannot deliver. Sales messages that invent customer counts are easy to challenge. A sketch that labels assumptions is safer than a sketch that looks certain.
02
Concept
Positioning — who it is for, what job, why this and not the alternative, and proof — is a sentence you can test, not a slogan contest. Name a person in a situation, the job they hire the offer to do, the alternative if you vanished, and the proof you hold. If proof is empty, say so. A line that could sit on a rival's door is not positioning. Cut adjectives until the alternative is clear.
Offer design states scope, price logic you supply, and what is not included. Scope is the work, the time, and the result you will hand over. Price logic is your reasoning from cost, time, or a comparison you choose. The model must not invent a price or a discount. Write exclusions in plain language. If you cannot deliver a part, put it in the exclusion list, not the headline.
A sales message has five moves: problem, cost of doing nothing, offer, proof, and next step. Cost of doing nothing is practical — time, risk, or a delay the buyer already feels — not a scare you made up. Do not invent customer counts. Say twelve offices only if you counted twelve. A landing page section list can follow the same five moves, plus a facts block and a question block.
A business-plan sketch covers problem, customer, offer, channel, cost assumptions labeled as assumptions, and risks. An assumption — a number or belief you have not verified — must stay visible, or the sketch pretends to be a forecast. Separate a brainstormed idea from a validated one. Brainstormed means no buyer, cost check, or channel test yet. Validated means those checks happened outside the chat and you can point to notes.
03
Real-world example
A tire job the rival cannot copy by accident
Samir tried a slogan, fast and friendly, and saw it could hang on any shop door. His positioning sentence named weekday commuters who must roll before the 7:40 train, the job of a safe tire before that train, the alternative of a shop that quotes three days, and proof from his own book that tire work is most of last month's jobs. He did not invent a customer count beyond the tally he wrote. The offer listed scope as tire, brake check, and a light test, price logic as his posted board, and an exclusion: no carbon frames. The sales message stopped at a next step he can keep, a weekday drop before noon.
04
Gemini demonstration
A realistic exchange. Open Gemini beside this page and try a version with your own facts.
You
Write one positioning sentence for Lantern Cycle. Who: weekday commuter who must make the 7:40 train. Job: safe tire before that train. Alternative: only if my pasted page supports it, otherwise write needs a source. Proof: my tally of 40 tire repairs and 6 tune-ups. Do not add friendly, affordable, or number one. Do not invent a customer count.
Gemini
Positioning sentence, with empty cells left empty. Who: a weekday commuter who must roll before the 7:40 train. Job: a safe tire in time for that train. Alternative: a shop that quotes three days, which you said is what the nearest pasted page implies. If the page does not actually say three days, this cell flips to needs a source. Proof: your tally, 40 tire repairs and 6 tune-ups, which supports tire work as the common job, not a claim that you are the fastest in the city. I am not adding friendly, affordable, or trusted. Those words fit any door. Why this shop: you do the job the same day when the board says so, and you refuse carbon frames so the promise stays narrow.
You
Now the sales message: problem, cost of doing nothing, offer, proof, next step. Offer scope is tire, brake check, and light test. Price stays my board. Exclusion: no carbon frames. Next step: weekday drop before noon. No hundreds of riders. Then list landing page sections, not the designed page.
Gemini
Sales message without a made-up crowd. Problem: a soft tire at dawn misses the train. Cost of doing nothing: one missed commute, which is a real inconvenience, not a story about ruin. Offer: tire, brake check, and light test, same-day only if your board says same-day. Proof: the tally you wrote, stated as your count, not as a rate. Next step: weekday drop before noon, the hour you said you can still finish. I will not write hundreds of riders or a star rating. Landing page sections can be: the train problem, the offer, the exclusion for carbon frames, the tally as proof, the noon step, and a question block. Price stays your board. I will not invent a discount to make the page feel complete.
05
Prompt breakdown
The prompt
Role: offer editor. Task: write positioning in four labeled lines: who, job, alternative, proof. Then write the offer: scope, price logic, exclusions. Constraints: price logic must quote the number or rule I type, or say missing price. Proof must quote a count or fact I typed, or say needs a source. Do not invent customer counts, awards, or reviews. If a line could be copied onto a rival without edit, mark it too generic. Separate a final line: brainstormed or validated, and say validated only if I pasted a buyer note, a cost check, or a channel test.
- Four labels force who, job, alternative, and proof instead of a slogan.
- Missing price and needs a source keep the model from inventing commercial facts.
- The rival test catches lines that are not really positioning.
- The brainstormed versus validated line stops a sketch from pretending to be a checked plan.
06
Common mistakes
Usually
Write a homepage and say thousands of happy riders trust us.
Better
Use only my tally. If a count is missing, write needs a source. Do not invent customers.
Usually
Make the offer sound complete. Hide anything we cannot do.
Better
State scope and write exclusions in plain language, including work I will not accept.
Usually
Turn this brainstorm into a validated business plan with confident forecasts.
Better
Label cost figures as assumptions until I verify them outside the chat.
07
Practice exercise
One sentence a rival cannot steal
Done when: A rival cannot put their name on your positioning without the proof line becoming false, and no count is invented.
08
Challenge
Proof or a blank
Write one positioning sentence for a real offer or for Samir's tire service: who, job, alternative, and proof. Then write the offer with scope, price logic you supply, and two exclusions. Draft the sales message with problem, cost of doing nothing, offer, proof, and next step. Delete any customer count you did not personally tally. You are done when a rival could not swap in their name without the proof cell becoming obviously false.
Hint: Read the sentence with the proof line covered. If it still sounds finished, the proof was decoration. Put the proof back in plainer words.
09
Key takeaways
- Positioning names who, the job, the alternative, and proof you actually hold.
- Offers state scope, your price logic, and what is not included.
- Sales messages use problem, cost of doing nothing, offer, proof, and next step, without invented counts.
- A plan sketch labels assumptions and does not call a brainstorm validated.
10